Letter to Health Minister Duclos about unfair drug pricing

The Honourable Jean-Yves Duclos
Minister of Health
Health Canada
Address Locator 0900C2
Ottawa Ontario K1A 0K9
By email: hcminister.ministresc@hc-sc.gc.ca

February 3, 2022

Dear Minister Duclos,

I am writing today to express my growing alarm over your government’s continued delay in implementing revised Regulations governing patent medicine pricing. Our office wrote to former Health Minister Minister Hajdu and yourself (in your capacity as President of the Treasury Board) on July 13, 2021 following its second postponement to urge the government to move forward on these critical regulatory changes. Unfortunately no action has taken place in this regard over the past few months, to the great detriment of all Canadians.

Fair drug pricing in Canada should have been implemented decades ago. Yet at a time when both physical and mental health are top of mind for millions of our country’s citizens, your government’s inaction is inexplicable and inexcusable. Repeatedly postponing these much-needed revisions only worsens the plight of countless Canadians in dire need of affordable medication.

Canadians, including federal public service employees represented by the Professional Institute of the Public Service of Canada, continue to pay drug prices far in excess of those found in comparable countries. The industry’s exorbitant prices also result in runaway drug costs for federal and provincial health care plans, including the Public Service Health Care Plan. Surely you find this as unacceptable as we do.

Your government first committed to tackling unfair drug pricing in 2016, yet almost 6 years later, very little progress has been made on this issue. COVID-19 should not be cited as a reason for delay, but as an impetus to expedite action. Implementing the revised Regulations, and, as a second step, a national Pharmacare plan, should be a top priority for your government at this time.

I am asking you, as Health Minister, to ensure that these Regulations take effect as soon as possible. I am sure you are aware that the Patent Medicine Price Review Board’s own research demonstrates that an evidence-based approach to drug pricing is long overdue. While a fair balance between profit and accessibility has been found in these Regulations, neither the government nor the people of Canada will benefit from them until they are actually implemented.

I look forward to your timely response on this urgent and critical matter.

Sincerely,

Jennifer Carr
President,
The Professional Institute of the Public Service of Canada


6 October 2017
Radio-Canada and the CBC have reported this week that Phoenix was “doomed from the start.” The reason? The business case prepared in 2009 under the previous government “lacked proper risk analysis and was politically motivated.” In the words of former parliamentary budget officer Kevin Page, “You look at this business case, you can drive trucks through some of the holes under the risk analysis.”

3 October 2017
In light of the Phoenix fiasco and as part of a commitment made to bargaining agents to make it easier for their members to obtain information about their pay, Public Services and Procurement Canada (PSCPC) has just released its Pay Bulletin for September.

2 October 2017
The Institute has just filed two new policy grievances on Phoenix-related issues, accusing the Treasury Board of failing to implement the terms of the AV and SP Group collective agreements within the specified timeframe (120 and 90 days respectively).

29 September 2017
While much has been reported about the impact of the Phoenix pay system on current federal employees, comparatively little has been said about the harm done to retirees.

21 July 2017
Recently, I sent an opinion piece to the Globe and Mail about our members’ ongoing problems with the Phoenix pay system and what I consider to be one of the root causes of the debacle: outsourcing.

12 June 2017
The recent recommendations of yet another consultants’ report on Shared Services Canada (SSC) demonstrate that, when it comes to federal government outsourcing, there’s no shortage of private sector advice.

You may also be interested in...